Wrapmation White Paper -- Roll Tracking on Personal Computers |
Roll tracking systems (RTS) provide computerized management and tracking of paper production and movement in a paper mill. This white paper examines Wrapmation’s application of recent technological innovations in personal computers (PC), how these developments influence RTS selection, and how Wrapmation's PC-based roll tracking systems enable customers to benefit from this technology.
This document also explains Wrapmation’s choice of the IBM PC, Microsoft Windows and our TRAQ Manager roll tracking system development environment. Our technical, financial and ergonomic assessment includes both the benefits and the challenges of Microsoft desktop technology in paper mill production management.
TRAQ Manager, Wrapmation's RTS solution, runs on all Windows platforms and on industry-standard networks such as Microsoft NT and Novell NetWare. Wrapmation's preferred platform is Windows NT because of its strength in the marketplace and versatility.
Look at any
desk in any paper mill. Chances are,
there is a PC on almost every one. Then look at what is running on those PCs.
They are probably running Microsoft Windows in one form or another, and many of
these PCs are part of the mill’s Novell or Microsoft networks.
In the office
desktop environment, Microsoft and Windows are unquestionably the leaders in
the desktop operating system marketplace.
Out on the factory floor, however, it is a different story – there are
no standards here. While Wrapmation
could have chosen one of many platforms, our choice of Windows for TRAQ Manager
provides the opportunity for a common unified computing environment throughout
a mill.
Why
Windows? Because of Microsoft’s
dominant position in office applications, we wanted to bring factory floor
automation in to this platform. This
allows clerks and customer service representatives to view what is happening on
the mill floor and make business decisions and analysis directly on a single
platform.
TRAQ Manager
office modules will run on all current versions of Windows -- and therefore can
probably run on most of the existing desktop workstations. Floor modules run
best on Windows NT.
Our clamp
truck industrial PC, similar to a PC notebook, is equipped with a touch
screen. The touch screen feature
minimizes typing or mousing around, and allows the operator to mind his driving
and his work.
The clamp
truck PC also contains a wireless Ethernet card, bridging the PC to the mill
network. This provides the clamp truck
operator with access to information in the TRAQ Manager database.
The TRAQ
Manager clamp truck runs Windows applications that provide the operator with
information such as: order status, production plans, inventory, and vehicle
availability. The clamp truck
workstation is a mobile decision-making tool, empowering the driver to make
informed decisions about roll storage, loading and other inventory-management
issues.
Everyone knows that Windows applications
are more fun to use. |
Windows NT offers many advantages as a computer platform. It is easy to use, robust, reliable and secure.
Regarding the bottom line, NT's entry-level costs are lower than those of mainframe or minicomputer-based systems. Overall, Windows-based systems cost less than Unix or proprietary technologies.
Windows NT is ideal for the desktop environment, in large part because of the popularity it has already earned throughout the marketplace. Another advantage is its use of the familiar Windows 95/98 interfaces.
Since Windows
NT can run on multiple hardware platforms, users are not limited to a single
technology or hardware vendor. At the
same time, that flexibility also includes the capability to support most
programs written for any Windows generations.
Looking ahead, it is quite reasonable to expect that future versions of
Windows will support existing applications.
Windows NT is
easy to learn and easy to operate. As
an added bonus, it is also FUN to use, especially compared to the
character-based systems common with mini and mainframe systems. These advantages reduce the stress in the
day-to-day working environment. This is
especially true on the plant floor where repetitive roll-production steps are
being automated.
Scalability
is our measure of how much and how easily a system can be expanded. While PCs are scaleable, we do consider Unix
to be superior in this area.
|
However, roll
tracking systems tend to be very static.
Changes to the system are usually to accommodate new customer and
business requirements. It is unlikely
that a roll tracking system will experience a tenfold expansion. On the other hand, PC scalability is
sufficient to handle mammoth operations such as large airline reservation
systems.
While an
organization may expand, the roll tracking system – like the paper mill itself
– will often be a static component in the enterprise. The mill must consider the degree of importance for system
scalability and the additional costs of maintaining a highly scaleable
system.
Scalability
is not a major roll tracking system selection criterion. However, the knowledge that there is room for expansion – if necessary –
provides peace of mind. IS managers
should be more concerned about the roll tracking system's connectivity into the
corporate platform.
Training is a
major cost of any system implementation.
It can be expensive, especially when instructor costs, staff overtime
pay, the learning curve and losses in production-level efficiencies are
factored in.
However, with
PC-based systems, training is no longer an expense. It is an investment – and one with a good return. We believe that having a computer- literate
staff will encourage better employee productivity. The skills acquired can encourage home-computer use, which will
in turn help to improve workplace skills and experience.
Windows-based
applications do require less training. This is because many operators are
already well acquainted with Windows through their use of other applications at
work as well as at home.
This
popularity of Windows reduces training costs and efforts during the start-up
phase. The same goes for any upgrade
activities, since enhancements will use common graphic user interfaces. Windows
means minimal operator training for system updates.
Another
advantage is that replacement employees can usually learn Windows applications
easily. Plus, your electronic
technicians probably already know how to install, maintain and troubleshoot PC-
and Windows-based systems. To further simplify
training efforts, Wrapmation does not modify any equipment. The original equipment manufacturers
normally will support their products.
Many paper
mills today already have a computer network infrastructure that usually
consists of standard Ethernet or Token Ring and one or more of the following
servers: NT, NetWare, Unix and others.
TRAQ Manager runs TCP/IP over Ethernet and can run with NT and NetWare
servers. TRAQ Manager also runs IPX/SPX
on NetWare.
Unlike mini-
and mainframe-based systems, TRAQ Manager was not specifically designed or adjusted to run on any particular
network. It was built on industry
networks, using industry-standard components and software. No custom work was done to make TRAQ Manager
run on industry networks.
For the mill
that already has a network, it will most likely be already compatible with TRAQ
Manager. For the mills that do not have
a network, industry standard TCP/IP networks -- especially PC-based networks --
are the de facto standard to be installed now-a-days. Users should be able to use one unified network, computers and
operating systems for their office automation as well as roll tracking
functions.
While the
Windows NT platform is more stable than other Windows releases, it is not
perfect, nor is it the most reliable or stable. However, as computer science advances, Wrapmation believes that
software crashes will become history -- even in Windows. With each successive Windows release, bugs
and memory leaks are rectified and reliability increases.
As an
analogy, consider the evolution of television technology. Sets used to be heavy, and equipped with
vacuum tubes. TVs took time to warm up,
and picture quality was inconsistent.
TV repairmen made house calls.
Today
however, TVs turn on instantly and seldom fail. If they did, you would probably have trouble finding a TV
repairman. Wrapmation believes that PCs will be just as reliable one day.
Windows NT
satisfies many security requirements – key variables in any computer-selection
criteria. Typically, Windows networks are password-protected, and enable system
administrators to determine which users can log in, from which locations, and
at which times.
Windows NT is built around a security kernel that ultimately protects the system itself. This kernel also enforces access controls that protect all sensitive files and data outside the kernel, affording complete protection. Windows NT offers system integrity, the foundation for all other security features. This is one of the strongest arguments in favor of the Windows NT Workstation for desktops at sensitive facilities.
Windows NT is one of the few commercial operating systems that has successfully completed the United States government’s C2 evaluation, as well as its European counterpart, the FC2/E3 evaluation under ITSEC. ITSEC is a major international security group.
With
the Microsoft Zero Administrative Kit (ZAK), system administrators can limit
end-user access to system files and unauthorized applications on the
workstation. This means fewer failures
resulting from operators’ accidental or malicious access to operating-system
components that is outside their day-to-day requirements.
The use of ZAK throughout a mill can reduce costs by:
·
Allowing
IS to lock down desktops and prevent end-user operations that result in
help-desk calls.
·
Providing
centralized desktop configurations.
·
Eliminating
end-user access to system files and features.
·
Prohibiting
unapproved application installations.
For more information, please see http://www.microsoft.com/ntserver
A cluster is
a set of loosely coupled, independent computer systems that behave as a single
system. With a cluster of servers, if
one server fails, others will instantly take over the workload. Until the failed server is replaced,
existing servers will automatically “pinch hit,” taking over the workload.
In 1997,
Microsoft released phase-one of its clustering solution; code-named
“Wolfpack.” At this early stage,
Wrapmation feels that this technology is unproven on NT. However, the Microsoft Windows NT
architecture does contain many of the basic components for clustered system
construction. Wrapmation expects that
the phase-two technology will be more viable, and assures customers that TRAQ
Manager will run on this platform.
Phase-two is projected for early 1999.
Mill IS
departments selecting any computer technology today should take a serious look
at the compatibility of that choice with Microsoft’s clustering solution. For that very reason, Wrapmation’s TRAQ
Manager runs on cluster-aware foundations such as MS‑SQL.
Many
Windows-based packages are available today.
TRAQ Manager makes extensive use of commercial software offerings such
as fax packages, electronic data interchange, Programmable Logic Controllers
(PLC) communications, spreadsheets, report writers and others.
Wrapmation
incorporates off-the-shelf software packages into TRAQ Manager to give our
customers feature-rich functionality for a fraction of what would otherwise
cost us millions of dollars to develop.
Packages such
as Symantec’s WinFax provide amazingly powerful and rich faxing functions. And they sell for just a couple of hundred
dollars.
Almost every
system vendor today has a PC solution. For example, recent PLC and gauging
system vendors should already have PC-friendly solutions. Wrapmation investigates your existing
equipment vendors’ PC solutions. Then
we try to integrate our technology with theirs. If we are both PC-based, the
construction of the glue software
between the two systems usually requires less customization effort. This should provide tighter integration and
lower costs.
TRAQ Manager
can support several protocols including TCP/IP, ODBC, API calls and OLE.
In most
cases, mills are responsible for much of their system hardware and operating
systems. Usually, mill technicians can
efficiently handle failed monitor or disk-drive replacements. However, Wrapmation is always available as
the second line of defense.
For software
support, TRAQ Manager uses a Symantec PC Anywhere program that automatically
answers the telephone when a Wrapmation technician calls. With PC Anywhere, Wrapmation personnel can
perform almost any on-site service function from remote locations.
To enable
this feature, a mill must provide a data-grade phone line that can be dialed
directly from outside the mill. This
offers full security since mill management can always disconnect the computer
system from the phone line. Other
technologies such as Point to Point Tunneling Protocol (PPTP) to enable
Internet access to the system.
For
after-hours support, a designated mill representative need only call a single
Wrapmation telephone number. The
Wrapmation operator will collect any relevant information and contact the
appropriate Wrapmation experts. The employee will evaluate the situation and
decide to contact other colleagues for additional support, or contact the
customer directly. Wrapmation technical
personnel are always within reach, either by pager or cellular phone.
TRAQ Manager
features a self-monitoring function for system health. For non-critical problems, TRAQ Manager
sends electronic mail to those responsible for system maintenance. Additionally, the system sends nightly
status reports to the appropriate support personnel. The electronic mailing list for reports can include both mill and
Wrapmation personnel. This proactive
feature enables Wrapmation to detect and resolve potential problems – often
before they noticed by the mill.
There are two
kinds of businesses: those that have
Internet services, and those that will
have Internet services. For businesses of the future, Internet access will
be as commonplace as telephone and fax access is today.
Wrapmation
has been a “business of the future” for many years. For instance, in 1994, we became the very first roll-tracking
supplier to have a web site.
Our TRAQ
Manager, with many points of Internet presence, is helping to bring our clients
into the future as well. First, TRAQ
Manager users can send and receive electronic mail to and from the system. TRAQ Manager uses your SMTP (Simple Mail Transport
Protocol) or UUCP (Unix to Unix Copy) gateway to send status reports and
diagnostic information. Order
acknowledgements, shipping confirmation and shipping details can also be sent
to customers via the same e‑mail gateway.
TRAQ Manager
can use HTML, the language of the World Wide Web, to create reports that can be
read from any Internet browser. This
enables reporting of inventory, production statistics and other useful
information on the Internet or Intranet.
TRAQ Internet
is Wrapmation’s web-based module providing interactive access to TRAQ Manager
from the World Wide Web. With TRAQ
Internet, sales representatives and clients can access TRAQ Manager through a
web browser. From anywhere on the
Internet, they can log into TRAQ Manager and investigate inventory status,
order status, shipment dates, quality certificates and much more.
The system
can incorporate high-security protocols like those used by web-based banks and
brokerage houses. TRAQ Manager security
can include 128-bit strong encryption and Secure Socket Layer (SSL).
The remote
client can include PC, Macintosh, Sun Workstations and other platforms with a
Java-Enabled browser. This makes TRAQ
Manager platform-independent.
The Internet
offers many exciting developments – and opportunities – for progressive paper
mill managers who take the lead in customer service.
Wrapmation
and Microsoft are committed to providing a tightly integrated platform for the
Internet.
Yes. TRAQ Manager software has been Year 2000 (or
Y2K) compliant since the product was first introduced in 1993.
The
TRAQ Manager system uses built-in intelligence for date manipulation. It does
not store dates as two-digit years as many other systems do. Rather, TRAQ
Manager stores dates as the number of days that have passed since a fixed date.
Using this paradigm, January 1, 2000 is merely one day greater than December
31, 1999.
Hardware
suppliers must be Y2K compliant also.
This issue is dependent on the hardware supplier since Wrapmation allows
mills to choose their own hardware.
Actually,
TRAQ Manager does run on clones (generic-brand computers). Wrapmation uses them extensively in our
offices.
For
production systems, however, Wrapmation recommends brand-name systems.
We do not
recommend the use of clones as file servers, since servers are the central
repositories of information that is critical to the mill. This includes information about orders,
production, inventory and shipping activities.
An hour of
lost production can cost in excess of $5,000.
The loss of the server or network or data can raise havoc. This cost
estimate does not account for the impact to the corporation of permanent data
loss on the server.
All network
operating systems suppliers, including Microsoft and Novell, have their own
hardware-compatibility (HCL) list of vendors and models that have been tested
under various operating conditions and are actively supported. With brand-name computers, customers are
alerted about the latest software drivers, engineering change orders and, most
importantly, information about hardware combinations that have experience
problems.
Most clone
manufacturers do not go this far in terms of customer support and product
testing.
Last but not
least, having brand name server provides confidence to management.
It is very
expensive to have 100 per cent perfectly secure system availability. An objective like 99.9 per cent uptime is
more realistic. Data integrity must be
100 per cent.
Redundant
mirrored disk drives for continuous data back-up reduce the risk of data
loss. The use of redundant servers and
network components allows instant or very fast service restoration after
experiencing a failed component.
For any
system that incorporates redundancy, the appropriate individuals must be
informed about partial component failures. That way, the failure can be repaired before there is any chance
of back-up component failure as well.
Brand name server manufactures provides many methods for alerting technicians
of component failures.
Brand-name
computer manufacturers such as Compaq and Hewlett Packard invest heavily in
research and production of superior products.
Wrapmation believes that brand-name products are better engineered and
these manufacturers offer superior support.
Since brand-name manufacturers have higher volumes, they can afford
better quality control programs that will ensure greater reliability. Also, brand-name vendors provide on-site
warrantees and more formal comprehensive product support – usually available
seven days a week, 24 hours a day.
Some may
argue that spare parts for clones are available just around the corner at local
computer stores. We feel that paper
mills must maintain complete spare parts on site for critical computer systems,
as they do for any production machinery.
Roll tracking systems are very much part of the mill’s production
machinery.
Brand-name
vendors are able to ship replacement parts within 24 hours, and technicians are
often available to come on-site to install these new components, often at no
charge. However, since most mills are outside
urban centers, mileage fees may apply, but these costs are small in relative
terms.
Some of the technology that brand-name servers and workstations incorporate to provide ultimate uptime includes:
§
Error
Checking and Correcting (ECC) Memory
A single memory bit error can crash a computer system. By using error checking and correcting (ECC) memory, the computer will survive memory failures. Most clones do not use the more expensive ECC memory.
§
Pre-failure
warranty
The Compaq pre-failure
warranty covers server products using Compaq’s Insight Manager. The Insight Manager software tool monitors
system hardware. When a computer is about to fail, the temperature may start to
rise, the power supply voltage may dip, memory error rates rise, and disk drives
will do more retries to get the data off the disk. When these events start to occur, Insight Manager software
automatically prints problem reports.
Customers need only fax this report to the manufacturer. The manufacturer then ships a new component
and the customer returns the soon-to-fail component before it fails. This is all free of charge during the
warrantee period, and it maximizes server uptime and prevents data loss.
The Pre-failure warranty
applies to Compaq servers, desktop and portable products using Intellisafe hard
drives and Compaq Insight Manager.
Wrapmation is an authorized reseller for various brand-name computers.
Clarion programming is three times faster
and ten times more accurate than conventional development environments. |
TRAQ
Manager’s database engine is MS-SQL and the front end is developed in Clarion.
Clarion is a
Rapid Application Development (RAD) package, which produce computer
programs. RAD tools enhance productivity
since they enable far faster coding than conventional environments such as
PowerBuilder, Delphi and Visual Basic.
RAD tools
generate much of the computer code and the code that is generated is
pre-tested. The result is a significant
reduction in the painstaking process of debugging one statement at a time.
No two paper
mill operations are identical, even if they are owned by the same corporation
and make the same product. Mills all
have specialty niche products, and different shipping methods that depend on
geography, ownership and culture.
Mills also
have different conversion and wrapping machinery. One mill may wrap rolls using an automated wrapline and another
mill may stretch wrap the rolls. One
mill may operate just-in-time (JIT) from the wrapline and another mill may
inventory rolls to serve markets where customers call in and purchase from
stock.
Since mills
produce lots of paper, the benefits and savings of automation can be better
leveraged if systems are customized to their needs. A finely tuned system will result in improved performance,
increased savings and reduced headaches.
For this
reason, roll tracking systems must always be customized for the particular mill
operation.
With RAD, we
can rapidly and economically customize our software modules to each mill’s
requirements. And almost as easily, we
can create the custom modules required to meet special needs.
Clarion
produces the actual software source code.
This generated source code can be further fine tuned for very specific
application. There is no need to be
stuck with “plain vanilla” code.
In fact,
parts of TRAQ Manager are also written in SQL stored procedures, C, Java,
Fortran, Assembler and some NT scripts.
We use the best tools for each job.
Still on the
subject of tools, Wrapmation does not believe that customers should be too
concerned about a package’s underlying software. Mill management, however, should be more concerned about the
final results: system reliability, data access, costs, and ease of system modification.
At
Wrapmation, we believe in using the right tools for the task at hand.
Oracle is an
excellent product, but it is designed for large enterprises and
enterprise-oriented applications, rather than roll-tracking applications. Roll tracking systems are more group or
departmental systems, usually employed in the finishing and customer service
departments. Mill production
environments place uniquely heavy demands on the database and this requires
tight integration into a responsive database for peak performance periods.
Oracle
requires large and powerful servers and client machines. It requires extensive computer resources
that may not be available at remote locations such as customers’ and partners’
sites, or in employees’ homes. Oracle
requires a Database Administrator to keep the database tuned and maintain its
integrity.
Oracle is not
optimized for Windows NT or NetWare. As
an enterprise solution, it is configured for enterprise operating systems such
as UNIX.
On the other
hand, Wrapmation’s TRAQ Manager PC client-server technology is built on
Microsoft MS-SQL. The design
methodology is relational using Entity Relationship diagramming and other
relational methodologies. Our databases
provide continuous operations during system backups, ODBC connectivity and many
other rich database features.
Oracle does
not accommodate customization of the look and feel of applications, so that you cannot do exactly what you
want. Oracle applications fit into an
Oracle framework for portability across multiple platforms. These applications have an Oracle “look and
feel” that is not transparent to Windows users.
MS-SQL’s self-tuning wizardry reduces can even eliminate the need for an on-site Database Administrator (DBA). TRAQ Manager actually runs well if nobody changes anything.
All data in the TRAQ Manager system is accessible through Seagate's Crystal Report Writer, DDE, SQL, ODBC or cut and paste. TRAQ Manager can export and replicate most of its data through industry-standard comma separated variable (CSV) files for access by other applications.
Clarion
allows us to read and write to various database formats including X-base
(Dbase), IBM DB II, Oracle, MS-SQL and many others.
Once
customers sign a standard non-disclosure agreement, Wrapmation provides
application source code at no charge.
Development environment, development tools and software development training
are available for an extra fee.
PC-based
systems offer many advantages. They are
the leading platforms today, and face no challengers in the foreseeable future.
While no-one
can guarantee that the PC is here to stay, system managers must consider the
momentum of PC technology in the market place.
For instance, in the last two years, every Request For Proposal received
by Wrapmation has specified a PC platform.
Wrapmation is
a roll tracking system pioneer, bringing this product to the standard PC
environment in 1993 – long before other vendors. Wrapmation experts’ experience is the product of more than 50
roll tracking installations worldwide.
For more information about TRAQ Manager and Wrapmation, contact WRAPMATION at (514) 846 9727 or email to: sales@wrapmation.com. Information can also be found at our website http://www.wrapmation.com.
________________________
© 1998,
Wrapmation Inc, All rights reserved.
This White
Paper is for informational purposes only.
Wrapmation makes no warranties, expressed or implied in this document.
TRAQ Manager
and TRAQ Internet are trademarks of Wrapmation Inc. Other product or company names mentioned in this document might
be trademarks of their respective owners.
Wrapmation
Inc. ¨ 4207 St. Catherine Street West ¨ Westmount, Quebec Canada H3Z 1P6